Wednesday, April 3, 2013

A Crisis Too Good To Waste By denationalising coal and cutting fuel subsidies, the government can kick-start economic repair

The country is in an economic crisis. The growth rate is coming down. The current account deficit (CAD) has reached 6.7%. A crisis provides an opportunity to take muchneeded decisions that one could not otherwise take. 

    The finance minister rightly identified the most important challenges facing the Indian economy as achieving fiscal stabilisation and reducing CAD. Yet, after the budget, the CAD has gone up. The main reasons for the high CAD, he pointed out, are increasing imports of coal, oil and gold and decreasing exports. 
    The specific measure suggested to reduce coal imports is to have private participation in coal mining through public-private partnership (PPP) with Coal India Limited (CIL), the public sector monopolist. Similarly, to increase oil exploration, a new exploration policy will be formulated where revenue sharing will be required instead of profit sharing as is done now. 
    To reduce gold imports the FM indicated that new investment instruments will be introduced that will be preferred by those who currently buy gold as a hedge against inflation and for capital gains. For promoting exports the finance minister promised to support whatever measures the Reserve Bank takes. 
    Would these work? Despite 
having adequate resources of coal to produce all that we need domestically, we imported 100 million tonnes of coal in 2011-12, nearly 25% of our consumption. Also, the 12th Plan projects import of 185 million tonnes of coal in 2016-17. CIL says they are stymied by environmental clearances. The ministry of environment and forests will argue that CIL should have planned better accounting for the time needed for environmental clearance. 
    Under the Coal Nationalisation Act, only public sector firms can mine coal. Some designated users are permitted to mine coal for their own use, which they cannot sell to others. Thus only 

public sector firms can sell coal and so CIL mines and sells most of the coal in India. Today, CIL already outsources many activities to private firms. In a sense thus, there is already some form of PPP in coal mining. 
    What could the new announcement bring? Would it attract private firms to mine coal when it is to be sold through CIL, at the price fixed by CIL? Would private firms get environmental clear
ances faster than CIL? It is highly unlikely. One can argue that since the private sector will be more efficient than CIL it will make excess profit if it gets the price that CIL gets. 
    However, since the CIL price is not market determined, it is uncertain when CIL will reset price and if the government will decide to subsidise coal as it does petroleum products. 
    The sensible response to the CAD and coal crises would be to denationalise coal completely and let coal price be market determined. Only then can we expect the private sector to come in in a substantial way and introduce new technology. That is the only way we can avoid the import of 185 million tonnes in 2016-17 as envisaged by the 12th Plan. 
    During UPA-I when i was member, Planning Commission, 
in charge of energy, we were told to suggest anything except denationalisation of coal. At that time one felt that this was because the UPA depended on the communist parties, which would never agree to it. Today, that constraint does not exist. Instead of reforming its coal policy, the government is taking patchwork actions that do not solve the fundamental problem. At this rate our energy security will be even more precarious than it is now, as we will depend on imports not only of oil but also of coal. 
    Even the short-term policy to deal with coal shortage shows the government's preference for bureaucratic non-market solutions. Today, CIL does not produce all the coal required by power plants, many of them operate below their capacity and power shortages persist. Since domestic 
coal is cheaper than imported coal, power plants are reluctant to import coal particularly when the coal cost pass through is not allowed by many state regulators. 
    CIL imports coal and charges a weighted average price of domestic and imported coal. A simpler, more efficient, solution would be to allocate domestic coal to all power plants on a pro rata basis and let the plants trade their allocations. Thus, a faraway coastal plant will sell the allocation to plants near the coalmines and import the coal it needs. The market will pool the price in a more efficient way. 
    To reduce oil imports we need to encourage efficient use and more exploration for oil and gas. Subsidies on diesel, LPG and kerosene need to be moderated if 
not eliminated and replaced by cash transfers to the really needy. That will increase the resources of domestic oil companies and their ability to explore and produce more oil domestically as well as acquire oil properties abroad. This is particularly important as the proposed bidding for revenue sharing increases perceived risk of oil exploration and is less likely to attract foreign firms. 
    Finally, to reduce gold import, inflation indexed bonds or bonds denominated in international gold price and tradable on an exchange at the prevailing gold price at any time, may be issued. Maybe the RBI can be persuaded to do this. 
    The writer is chairperson, Integrated Research and Action for Development.

Patchwork solutions can no longer reform the coal sector



Monday, March 25, 2013

Rural folk driving own economy

Mumbai: Indian villages are powering their own economy, but contrary to conventional belief, it's not government largesses which are the drivers, but their own self-sustaining models. Growth at the bottom of the pyramid is at unprecedented level, and the transformation is stark. 

    The factors driving this transformation are dramatic improvements in rural roads, electrification, cell phones and water supply which are raising wages and increasing job opportunities for thousands living in villages. This, in turn, is fuelling demand for consumer goods, and for those companies which have a strong rural push. 
    Case studies from fieldtrips and research undertaken by Credit Suisse show that the growth in productivity is 
becoming sustainable as jobs in manufacturing drive services jobs in transportation and trade, enabled by mobile phones and roads. 
    Research over the last couple of years by independent sources has confirmed that 
use of cell phones benefited a diverse set of people—from fishermen to sari weavers. Most of the studies focused on price discovery in agriculture or on skilled artisans improving customer service or price realizations. 
    D K Joshi, chief economist at Crisil, says, "Overall, there has been a definite improvement in the rural economy. Villages have become self sustaining, providing a big push in manufacturing jobs. Roads are increasing demand for vehicles, while cell phones trigger more goods and services. However, a lot more is required; the success stories need to be replicated in a number of areas." 

CHANGING FACE OF INDIAN VILLAGES 

    Village textile stores now stock pre-stitched branded clothing 
    The second hottest-selling item in a rural grocery store is packaged 
gulab jamun instant mix 
    Rural areas have a higher penetration of direct-to-home 
devices for receiving TV content 
Two in every five mobile subscribers are now rural 
40% of demand for cement comes from rural housing 
Most surprisingly, poultry farming created more days of work per person than the jobs guarantee programme (between 2005 and 2010) 
Rising wages, land prices spur rural purchasing power 
Mumbai: The face of the rural Indian economy is changing for the better. Access to roads is helping landless people raise poultry (chicken) within limited floor space and sell their produce in nearby towns. In fact, poultry farming created 3.8 million jobs between 2005 and 2010: the 950 million person days of work thus created every year is the same as that by the government's NREGA in the same period. 
    Road access significantly improves land prices, labour mobility, wages and alternative employment avenues, says a study by Credit Suisse. 
    For example, production of mannequins has moved from Ulhasnagar outside Mumbai to villages in Rajasthan, while other examples like pottery (Orissa), saris (West Bengal), furniture (Himachal Pradesh), are all potential jobs difficult to carry out in remote villages previously, but are now made easy by road connectivity. 
    The study found a strong correlation between per-capita output and road networks (represented by vehicle penetration) both within and across states. 
    Since about 80% of the country's rural households own less than two acres of land, 
they are therefore wage dependent. Analysts point out that this wage growth is largely productivity-driven (and therefore sustainable to a large extent), providing a floor to India's cratering economic growth, and even in the absence of major infrastructure projects taking off, there are substantial changes in basic infrastructure that are taking place in areas other than big cities. 
    Over the last five years, rural wages have increased at an unprecedented 20% CAGR, with land prices appreciating sharply as well. Both have ended up putting more money in the hands of people, and generating purchasing power, experts say. Fast-moving consumer goods companies are enthused with the strong rural demand as it augments their sales. 

    In some cases like Emami with products, offered in 30 lakh rural outlets, including Navratna Oil, Fair and Handsome cream, Zandu Balm, BoroPlus cream, has nearly 50% of sales in some categories coming from rural markets.
    Says N Krishna Mohan, CEO, sales, supply chain & human capital, "We are going to focus on specific brands/stock keeping units and increased outlet coverage in villages/ 
towns in certain states where we have a strong direct coverage. In other markets, we would be working on ensuring that at least 80% of the villages with a population of 10,000 and above are put under the coverage map by the end of the next fiscal". 
    Another company, ITC, which offers Sunfeast biscuits, Vivel soaps, Superia soaps and shampoos, has been able to tap the rural segment through its e-choupal network. Says an ITC executive: "The divide between urban and rural markets has narrowed down and hence we have expanded our basket of offerings in rural India. Given the vast reach and penetration, ITC has devised mobility solutions for monitoring progress and instant information dissemination". 

    Sales of white goods like refrigerators, and consumer durables like LCD televisions have surged in villages. 
    Private banks have also realized that villages can be the next engine of growth. This is because the share of saving deposit for non-urban branches is high (42-50%) as against the 15-30% in metro/urban branches.




Custom Search

Ways4Forex

Women of 21st Century

India: As it happens